If you like consistency in your hobby experience, then 1991 Upper Deck baseball cards were right up your alley.
Not only did Upper Deck’s third issue present the same basic clean white motif with stunning photos on both card fronts and backs as the 1989 and 1990 sets, but it completed a theme.
Namely, with their 1991 issue, UD came all the way home — the 1989 design featured the first-base line, the 1990 cards had the path from first to second covered, and the 1991s rounded third and raced in for the score.
And, while time has revealed that these dandies were just about as overproduced as all the other 1991 cards, that consistent and high-quality presentation, along with a strong crop of rookie cards, has kept collector interest simmering along.
Here, then, are the ten most popular 1991 Upper Deck baseball cards, as ranked by the number of cards submitted to PSA for grading over the years, according to their Population Report.
Play ball!
1991 Upper Deck Chipper Jones (#55)
This was the era when the rookie card mania from the 1980s met the massive hype and proliferation of cards and sets of the 1990s to ensure that every player had at least a few hundred different rookie cards (hyperbole alert) … and, as early as possible.
So, even though Chipper wouldn’t make his Major League debut until 1993, and even though he wasn’t an actual rookie until 1995, he landed on a “Top Prospect” card here in 1991.
He really was a top prospect, though, and this card has been popular for three decades and counting. That amazing career Jones put together with the Braves, along with a spot in Cooperstown, don’t hurt this card’s swagger any.
Check prices on eBay (affiliate link)
Check prices on Amazon (affiliate link)
1991 Upper Deck Jeff Bagwell (#755)
Bagwell, on the other hand, landed his UD rookie card just in the nick of time.
After a trade deadline swap that sent him from the Boston Red Sox to the Houston Astros for Larry Andersen in 1990, Bags settled in at first base to open the 1991 season.
He didn’t look back until he was in the Hall of Fame, right there beside fellow Killer B, Craig Biggio.
Probably even more than the Jones card, this Bagwell RC found an immediate home with collectors, driven by Baggy’s Rookie of the Year award in 1991 and his persistent appearance on MVP ballots (he won the award in 1994).
Check prices on eBay (affiliate link)
Check prices on Amazon (affiliate link)
1991 Upper Deck Mike Mussina (#65)
Like Jones, Mussina got the “prospect” treatment in this set, but he made his debut later in that same summer of 1991.
By the next spring, Moose was ensconced in the Orioles’ rotation, and he would develop into one of the most consistently excellent pitchers in the game over the next two decades.
Mussina’s profile, and that of his cards, got a boost when he moved on to the Yankees in 2001 and helped them capture two American League pennants (2001, 2003).
Though Moose never won a World Series, he did win a Cooperstown plaque in 2019, which always does good things for a fella’s cards.
Check prices on eBay (affiliate link)
Check prices on Amazon (affiliate link)
1991 Upper Deck Luis Gonzalez (#567)
It’s sort of ironic that Gonzalez shows up as a first baseman for the Astros here on his Upper Deck rookie card given that Bagwell is similarly designated.
Bags, of course, ultimately won the competition at first, with Gonzalez sliding into left field.
Gonzo was solid but unspectacular throughout his Houston tenure, and then in stops with the Cubs and Tigers.
But a 1999 trade that sent him from Detroit to the Arizona Diamondbacks changed the complexion of his career — in eight seasons in the desert, Gonzalez smacked 224 home runs, hit .298, and became a bona fide star … all in his 30s.
That run included a gaudy 57 home runs in 2001, the same year his walk-off single in the bottom of the ninth of game 7 off Mariano Rivera drove in Jay Bell to give the Snakes their first World Series title ever.
Stuff like that tends to make a guy’s rookie card sort of popular … forever.
Check prices on eBay (affiliate link)
Check prices on Amazon (affiliate link)
1991 Upper Deck Frank Thomas (#246)
Since Thomas had a handful of rookie cards in the various 1990 sets — but not UD — this one technically qualifies as a first Upper Deck card, and not really a rookie card.
Collectors of the day, though, treated this one pretty much on par with the Bagwell rookie as both players heated up that summer.
Thomas had already exhausted his rookie status in 1990, but his 32 home runs, 109 RBI, .318 batting average, and 1.006 OPS in 1991 lit up the game and the hobby.
Big Hurt crashed hobby hotlists right off the bat, and he remained a popular figure all throughout his 19-year Hall of Fame career, and beyond.
Check prices on eBay (affiliate link)
Check prices on Amazon (affiliate link)
1991 Upper Deck Mark McGwire (#174)
Big Mac would hit the first bump in his career road the summer this card was issued, bottoming out with a .201 batting average and just 22 home runs.
He would rebound to a large extent in 1992 before injuries (and The Strike) limited him to just 178 games from 1993 through 1995.
Of course, it all turned around in 1996, when he topped 50 home runs for the first time, and then came the historic homer barrage in the late 1990s. That rocketed his cards to the top of the hobby, and, though the steroid scandal that followed dinged his reputation significantly, McGwire maintains a strong collector base even today.