The arrival of Mike Piazza rookie cards marked a couple of monumental milestones, both in the game and in the hobby.
On the diamond, Piazza set the stage for the onslaught of his first cards into the market by rising from a 62nd-round pick in the 1988 MLB Draft to a legitimate blue-chip prospect. To wit, he chipped away at his game in the low minors for a couple of seasons before smacking 29 home runs at high-A Bakersfield in 1991.
Then, in 1992, he blew the doors off Double-A and Triple-A pitching and landed in Los Angeles to finish the season.
No longer a charity case selected out of courtesy to close family friend and Dodgers manager Tommy Lasorda, Piazza could do anything he wanted with the bat, and his progress as a catcher was impressive enough that folks started to wonder if he might be the guy to take over for the aging Mike Scioscia (who would retire as a player after the 1992 season).
In the hobby, there was at least one group who had already hitched their wagons to Piazza’s rising star even before his Chavez Ravine debut — the decision-makers at Topps who were planning the checklist for their revamped Bowman line.
More about that later, but suffice it to say that a premature Mike Piazza rookie card helped shape the future for both Bowman and RCs in general.
It also sort of muddied the water for Piazza cards, leaving him with only one true rookie card, which we’ll define as the first base card(s) with wide national distribution (i.e., in packs) and showing him in his Dodgers uniform.
But that’s OK, because there were plenty of cards issued during Piazza’s actual rookie season, in 1993.
So …
What follows is a rundown of Mike Piazza rookie cards, with some liberties taken with that term in order to enhance our overall hobby experience.
Play ball!
(Note: The sections below contain affiliate links to eBay and Amazon listings for the cards being discussed.)
1992 Bowman Mike Piazza Rookie Card (#461)
When collectors got our first gander when it was released in August of 1992, the revamped Bowman set sort of blew our socks off.
Gone were the mushy brown cardstock, oversize card dimensions (in 1989, at least), simple vintage design (which was actually pretty elegant), and Topps-y card backs, replaced by crisp creamy-white cardboard, UV coating, color photos front and back, and … rookies!
After three years of sort of flopping around with what they wanted to do with the resurrected corpse of their old mortal enemy, Topps had finally settled on a destiny for Bowman: it henceforth and forevermore would be known as THE place to go for rookie cards.
And also, like, not-really-rookie-cards-but-cards-of-guys-who-you-might-someday-want-a-rookie-card-of-and-when-you-do-there-will-be-a Bowman-card-to-fill-that-void cards.
It’s how we ended up with senior pictures of Mariano Rivera and Manny Ramirez, and why we have to look at new cards today that actually tell us they’re rookie cards right there on the card front: “RC” or “Rookie Card.”
Thanks for the tip. It’s all very self-referential and meta.
But Topps’ picking a lane is also how we ended up with the one true Mike Piazza rookie card, even if it was issued a month before his big-league cup was, and had to have been planned for a while before that.
When Piazza stuck with the Dodgers for good then next spring, and then when he showed that his power game held up just fine in the majors, where did we turn?
Yeah, we dove into his 1992 Bowman rookie card, and the issue’s place in history was set.
Bowman floated Piazza a cardboard loan late in 1992, and then the 1993 National League Rookie of the Year returned the solid by making the cardboard look like a crystal ball.
Value: $35-40
Check prices on eBay (affiliate link)
Check prices on Amazon (affiliate link)
1992 Fleer Update Mike Piazza Rookie Card (#U-92)
I haven’t done the math on all the rookies or traded guys who have ever appeared in a Traded or Update set, but my gut tells me that Fleer hedged their bets with Mike Piazza in 1992.
Take Pete Rose, for instance.
His 1984 base cards show him with the Phillies, even though he had signed with the Expos in the offseason. Then, on August 16, the ‘Spos traded him to the Reds.
That fall, Rose appeared in both the Topps Traded and Fleer Update sets … with Montreal.
So, August 16 was too late to get The Hit King right, but September 1 (the date Piazza debuted with the Dodgers in 1992) was just fine for a 62nd-rounder?
OK.
So, Fleer probably bought the Lasorda +“minor league homers” + Pretty Woman hype and planned to issue a Piazza card all along. That’s fine, and it got us another early look at a soon-to-be baseball legend.
They just forgot to add the official “Disingenuous” hologram to card backs, is all.
Value: $80-85
Check prices on eBay (affiliate link)
Check prices on Amazon (affiliate link)
1992 Donruss ‘The Rookies’ Phenoms Mike Piazza Rookie Card (#BC-9)
The last fully licensed “rookie card” of Mike Piazza issued in 1992 came into existence in an unusual way.
See …
For six years, Donruss “The Rookies” greeted collectors each fall from the confines of a 56-card box set. In 1992, though, on the heels of a popular base set with a refreshed design, Donruss branched out – “The Rookies” featured a whopping 132 cards and were issued only in packs.
It all spelled the end of the line for “The Rookies,” though, as the set disappeared into the ether … until it showed up again nearly a decade later after the Donruss-Playoff merger.
Before it rode off into the sunset (the first time), though, the upgraded year-end “The Rookies” issue graced us with an insert set of its own … which is sort of the cardboard equivalent of the sixth layer of indention on the outline you did for your high school term paper.
Anyway …
Phenoms was a 20-card run of the “top” top rookies, plus the best prospects in the game, in Donruss’s estimation.
Piazza made the cut at #BC-9, which meant he was inserted in “normal” packs along with the other members of the first 12 cards. The final eight on the checklist were inserted in 30-card jumbo packs.
As for the Piazza card itself, the design features sort of drab black and gray borders with a 90s-font “phenoms” that really hasn’t aged all that well. I call home run trot on the photo since Piazza appears to be moving around the bases, but with his eyes down, not really looking for the ball.
Or he’s leaning on a cane. One of the two.
Value: $35-45
Check prices on eBay (affiliate link)
Check prices on Amazon (affiliate link)
1993 Donruss Mike Piazza Rated Rookie Card (#209)
Now we come to the Fudge portion of our program, where you have to loosen your rigor in defining “rookie card” and let the hobby winds take you where they will.
Because, while the following pasteboards are *not* strictly rookie cards, you will definitely see them referred to as such by collectors, dealers, and liquidators from all walks of hobby life.
And, each card below has at least one or two redeeming characteristics that you demand from a real RC.
So, onto our not-really-rookie-card Mike Piazza rookie cards …
This is Piazza’s first Donruss base card and the one we were pulling from packs even as the young catcher was wowing the baseball world during his first full season with the Dodgers.
Plus, it features a nice, bright photo of Piazza that highlights the classic Dodger home uniform.
PLUS plus, it says “Rookie” right on the card front.
Value: $10-12
Check prices on eBay (affiliate link)
Check prices on Amazon (affiliate link)